How shady dairies killed 8,000 babies and sparked America’s first food laws
You wouldn’t think a 19th century milk scandal would be super relevant today, but new food safety rollbacks are setting us up for a deadly public health crisis we’ve seen before.
This spring, the FDA announced an end to our quality control program that tests milk and other dairy products for contaminants, parasites, and spoilage. They’ve stopped testing for bird flu, too. After DOGE fired 20,000 employees, there’s just not enough staff left for reliable oversight.
The good news is, this might just be a temporary pause while the FDA negotiates new deals with labs and contractors. They aim to be back on track by October. But that timeline feels wildly optimistic in light of White House plans to slash $40 billion from Health and Human Services — the agency that not only funds the FDA, but helps guard every bite we eat, from field to factory to fork.
It’s almost like we’ve forgotten why we test our food in the first place. 🤦
🧑🏫 TRUE STORY: The very first food safety laws in this country came from a scandal so stomach-turning, it made headlines across the world. It involved whiskey mash, animal cruelty, doctored milk, and the deaths of thousands of babies.
The Swill Milk Scandal wasn’t just another Victorian Era health crisis. It was an exposé of unchecked capitalism, backroom politics, and industrial greed. In cities like Philly, Boston, and Chicago, infants were dying in droves. In New York alone, more than 8,000 babies perished in just one year from what doctors at the time called “summer complaint” — relentless diarrhea, dehydration, and wasting.
No one knew what was going on. Some blamed cholera. Others, of course, blamed the mothers. But the real culprit was hiding in plain sight. It looked like milk. It was sold as milk. The label even said “Pure Country Milk.” But it was swill. Literally.
Swill milk was the thin, bluish runoff of a gruesome urban industry that turned dying cows into liquid poison. 🤢
To meet the rising demand for cheap milk in booming cities, whiskey distilleries started keeping cows in on-site sheds, feeding them the steaming, spent mash left over from alcohol production. It had no nutritional value. Cows starved, developed sores, their hooves rotted and their tails broke off. Some grew so sick they couldn’t stand — so workers slung them up in harnesses to milk them mercilessly to death.
The milk was watery, off-color, foul-smelling, and often full of pus, hair, bugs, worms, and other impurities. To cover it up, producers added chalk, gypsum, or paint for whiteness, starch or flour for texture, cinder or burnt sugar to neutralize odors and flavors, and formaldehyde to slow spoilage. It was sold on the cheap to the working poor, to desperate mothers who couldn’t afford better, and had no choice but to trust the label.
Swill milk was legally marketed as wholesome nutrition by shifty businesses with no real interest in feeding babies. For them it was all about profiting from a system where women were needed as workers, but denied the resources to safely care for their children. Maternal instinct is strong, though, and it was surely a mother who tipped off the press…
One morning in 1858, local newspaper publisher Frank Leslie discovered a jar of swill milk on his porch, and he was so revolted he immediately launched a full investigation. His reporters trailed milk wagons back to the source. His artists sketched the squalid barns, the mangled cows, the diseased udders. Readers were horrified. Nauseated. Outraged.
The distillery owners? Completely unconcerned.
This was the Tammany Hall era, when corruption was the cost of doing business. With no laws in place and no regulators watching, these operations ran with impunity. Health inspectors were bribed. Public hearings were stacked to mock reformers. And the lies! Authorities defended swill milk as “just as good” — even “better” — than fresh milk. The Board of Health, deeply compromised, gave the dairies a clean bill.
Public pressure continued, until finally in 1862, New York State passed the country’s first milk safety regulations. The new laws, however, were poorly enforced. Senseless deaths continued: fully two in every ten children died before the age of one! Real progress didn’t come until decades later, when a department store magnate stepped in where government had failed.
Nathan Straus, the German-born Jewish immigrant best known as a co-owner of Macy’s, used his personal fortune to fund a pasteurized milk laboratory. In 1892, he began distributing purified milk to the city’s poorest neighborhoods. He opened public milk stations where mothers could safely feed their babies. His efforts are credited with directly saving more than 445,000 children’s lives — and influencing mandatory pasteurization laws that saved millions more.
The term “woke” wasn’t a thing in the Gilded Age, but this was one tycoon who understood that people mattered more than margins — especially the smallest and most vulnerable among us. Milk is our first food: a symbol of trust, nurture, love, and motherhood. The idea that someone would knowingly poison it — and profit from that harm — still lands like a gut punch.
And yet… here we are. 🤷 The same logic that gave us swill milk is once again shaping America’s food policy towards cheap, careless, and unreliable standards. Don’t we know how this story ends? 🤔
🍽️ TOXIC TREATS & FILTHY FEASTS: A Brief History of Food Fraud
More barf-worthy reasons to support strong food safety regulations
💀 Bread & Alum (1800s, UK/US) To bulk out flour, bakers added chalk and alum — a whitening agent that also causes constipation, nutrient malabsorption, and long-term digestive issues. “Health bread,” indeed.
🍬 Poison Candy (1840s, UK) Dr. William O’Shaughnessy found that British candies contained lead, mercury, and other heavy metals — thanks to unregulated colorants. Bright green sweets were often dyed with copper arsenite. Children paid the price.
🍷 Antifreeze Wine (1985, Austria) Austrian producers added diethylene glycol (used in antifreeze) to sweeten cheap wine. The scandal spread across Europe and the U.S., prompting bans and bottles pulled from shelves.
🐎 Horsemeat Lasagna (2013, Europe) Beef products across the EU were revealed to contain up to 100% horsemeat. The supply chain was so opaque that even major brands had no idea what they were selling.
🍼 Melamine Milk (2008, China) Over 300,000 infants fell ill after Chinese baby formula was spiked with melamine to fake high protein levels. Six babies died. The scandal prompted global recalls and arrests.
🥫 Mystery Tuna (2015–present, Global) Tests show that up to 20% of tuna in the U.S. and Europe isn’t tuna at all. Often it’s escolar (nicknamed “the laxative fish”) — mislabeled and potentially harmful.
🫒 Fake Olive Oil (Ongoing, Global) One of the most commonly adulterated foods. Cheap oils cut with chlorophyll and beta-carotene to pass as “extra virgin.” Sometimes laced with soybean oil, triggering allergic reactions.
🍯 Honeygate (2011, US/China) U.S. authorities uncovered massive honey smuggling operations, with Chinese honey illegally routed through other countries and tainted with antibiotics and heavy metals.
🌭 Pink Slime (2000s–present, US) Officially known as “lean finely textured beef,” this ammonia-treated meat paste was used in burgers and school lunches without consumer knowledge until exposed in 2012.
Of course this is just the tip of the iceberg — and we haven’t even mentioned drugs and supplements, yet. Bon appétit!
❓🫵 What do you think? Click the links for more info, and please leave your questions and comments below.
Be the first to comment